CONSENSUS AND DISSENT IN RESTORATIVE JUSTICE
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.25192/issn.1982-0496.rdfd.v28i12303Abstract
The article discusses the theoretical ambiguities and conceptual vagueness present in the restorative justice movement. Based on the review of classical contributions and the ongoing international controversy, we systematize the elements that constitute the core of the restorative international consensus and the central elements of the dissent that has been growing, especially the contrasting positions between the "purist" and "maximalist" visions. We then examine, based on a search through Google Scholar, the ten articles published in Portuguese and authored by Brazilian researchers best placed in the bibliometric ranking of the Publish or Perish software. We find that the previously discussed theoretical ambiguities and indefinitions make restorative strands possible in Brazil with contrasting positions, which suggests the need for a more consistent theoretical basis for the restorative movement. We conclude by suggesting a path for overcoming some of the existing polarizations.
Downloads
References
ACHUTTI, Daniel. Justiça restaurativa no Brasil Possibilidades a partir da experiência belga. Civitas, Porto Alegre, v.13, n.1, 2013, p.154-181.
ADLER, Joanna R; MIR, Mansoor. Evaluation of The Forgiveness Project within prisons, 2012. Middlesex University’s Research Repository [London]. Disponível em: https://eprints.mdx.ac.uk/9401/. Acesso em: 13 fev. 2021.
AGUINSKY, Beatriz; CAPITÃO, Lúcia. Violência e socioeducação: uma interpelação ética a partir de contribuições da Justiça Restaurativa. Revista Katálysis. Florianópolis, v. 11, n. 2, 2008, p. 257-264.
ANDRADE, Vera Regina Pereira de. Pilotando a Justiça restaurativa: o papel do Poder Judiciário. Conselho Nacional de Justiça - CNJ. Brasília – DF, 2017. Disponível em: https://www.cnj.jus.br/wp-content/uploads/2011/02/722e01ef1ce422f00e726fbbee709398.pdf. Acesso em: 08 set. 2020.
AZEVEDO, R. G. de; PALLAMOLLA, R. da P. Alternativas de resolução de conflitos e justiça restaurativa no Brasil. Revista USP, v.101, 2014, p.173-184.
BARABÁS, Tunde; FELLEGI, Borbála and WINDT, Szandra. Responsibility-taken, Relationship building and Restoration in prisons: mediation and restorative justice in prison settings. Foresee Research Group and The National Institute of Criminology, European Commission, Budapest, 2012. Disponível em https://www.euforumrj.org/en/mereps-2009-2012 . Acesso em: 04 out. 2020.
BAZEMORE, Gordon; WALGRAVE, Lode. Restorative juvenile justice. Repairing the harm of youth crime. NY: Criminal Justice Press,1989. 399 p.
BEECH, Anthony R.; CHAUHAN. Evaluating the effectiveness of the Supporting Offenders through Restoration Inside (SORI) Programme delivered in seven prisons in England and Wales. Legal and Criminological Psychology [UK], 2012.
BENDER, John. The birthplace of restorative justice, Mennonite Central Commitee, 2019 [CA]. Disponível em: https://mcc.org/stories/birthplace-restorative-justice. Acesso em: 02 nov. 2020.
BRAITHWAITE, J.; PARKER, Christine. Restorative justice is republican justice. In G. Bazemore & L. Walgrave (Eds.). Restorative juvenile justice: Repairing the harm of youth crime, pp. 103-126. Monsey, NY: Criminal Justice Press, 1999.
BRANCHER, L. N. Manual de práticas restaurativas. Brasília: PNUD, 2006, v.1.
CRAWFORD, Adam; NEWBURN, Tim. Recent development in Restorative Justice for Young People in England and Wales. British Journal of Criminology [UK], v. 42, 2002, p. 476-495.
CROCKER, Diane. Implementing and Evaluating Restorative Justice Projects in Prison, Criminal Justice Policy Review, [US], v. 26, n.1, 2015, p. 45–64.
CONSEDINE, Jim. The Maori restorative tradition. In: A Restorative Justice Reader, Gerry Johnstone (Ed), William Publishing, UK, 2003, p.152-157.
DALY, Kathleen. Restorative justice: the real story. Punishment and Society, 4,1, 2002. p. 55-79. Disponível em:
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/29457851_Restorative_Justice_The_Real_Story Acesso em: 09 dez. 2020.
DALY, Kathleen. What is Restorative Justice? Fresh Answers to a Vexed Question, Victims & Offenders, [UK], v. 11, n.1, 2015, p. 9-29.
DARLING, Justine. Restorative Justice: A Tool in Rebuilding Post-Conflict Northern Ireland, University of San Diego. 2011. Disponível em: https://digitalcollections.sit.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1071&context=conflict_reconcilation_symposium Acesso em: 05 jan. 2021
DOOLIN, Katherine. But What Does It Mean? Seeking Definitional Clarity in Restorative Justice. The Journal of Criminal Law, [US], 2015, p. 427-440.
DUBOIS, Christophe; VRANCKEN, Didier. Restorative detention or ‘work on self’? Two accounts of a Belgian prison policy. Ethnography, [US], v. 16, n.2, 2015, p. 87-206.
DUNCAN, Susan Hanley. Workplace Bullying and the Role Restorative Practices Can Play in Preventing and Addressing the Problem, Industrial Law Journal, [UK], v. 32, 2011, p. 2331-2366.
FROESTAD, Jan; SHEARING, Clifford. Prática da Justiça: o Modelo Zwelethemba de Resolução de Conflitos. In: Slakmon, C., R. De Vitto, e R. Gomes Pinto (org). Justiça Restaurativa, Brasília – DF, Ministério da Justiça e Programa das Nações Unidas para o Desenvolvimento - PNUD, 2005, p. 79-124.
GRIFFIN, Diarmuid. Restorative Justice: A Real Alternative? Irish Criminal Law Journal, [Cork, IE], v. 15, n. 2, 2005.
HARRIS, M. K. Alternative visions in the context of contemporary realities. In P. Arthur (Ed.). Justice: The restorative vision. New perspectives on crime and justice, Issue #7. (pp. 31-40). Akron, PA [US]: Mennonite Central Committee Office of Criminal Justice, 1989.
HARZING, A.W. Publish or perish, 2007.
Disponível em: https://harzing.com/resources/publish-or-perish Acesso em: 11 set. 2021
HAYDEN, Carol. Restorative Justice, Restorative Approaches and Schools, Institute of Criminal Justice Studies, University of Portsmouth, UK, 2012. Disponível em: https://www.crimetalk.org.uk/library/section-list/38-frontpage-articles/817-restorative-justice-restorative-approaches-schools.html. Acesso em: 05 mar. 2020.
HOPKINS, B. Just Schools: A Whole School Approach to Restorative Justice. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers, 2004.
JACCOUD, Mylène. Princípios, Tendências e Procedimentos que Cercam a Justiça restaurativa. In: Slakmon, C., R. De Vitto, e R. Gomes Pinto (org). Justiça Restaurativa, Brasília – DF, Ministério da Justiça e Programa das Nações Unidas para o Desenvolvimento - PNUD, 2005, p.163-188.
JOÃO, Camila Ungar; ARRUDA, Eloisa de Souza. A Justiça Restaurativa e sua implantação no Brasil. Revista da Defensoria Pública da União, Brasília, DF, n. 7, 2014, p. 187-210.
JOHARI, Aiza; MORNI, Affidah; FARIDAH, Dayang; BOHARI, Abang; SAHARI, Siti Huzaimah. Conflicting Environment at Workplace: UiTM Sarawac’s lecturers, Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, [UK], v. 101, 2013, p. 554-563. Disponível em: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S187704281302123X Acesso em: 10 jan. 2021.
KONZEN, A. Justiça restaurativa e ato infracional: desvelando sentidos no itinerário da alteridade. Porto Alegre: Livraria do Advogado, 2007.
McCOLD, Paul. Toward a holistic vision of restorative juvenile justice: A reply to the maximalist model, Contemporary Justice Review, [UK], v. 3, n.4, 2000, p. 357-414.
McLAUGHLIN, Eugene; JOHANSEN, Anja. A Force for Change? The prospects of applying restorative justice to citizen complaints against the police in England and Wales, British Journal of Criminology, [UK], v. 42, 2002, p. 635-653.
McLEOD, Laura. Reconciliation throught Restorative Justice: Analyzing South Africa’s Truth and Reconciliation Process. George Mason University, 2015. Disponível em: https://www.beyondintractability.org/library/reconciliation-through-restorative-justice-analyzing-south-africas-truth-and-reconciliation Acesso em: 05 jan. 2021
MARSHAL, Tony F. Restorative Justice: an overview. In: A Restorative Justice Reader, Gerry Johnstone (Ed), William Publishing, UK, 2003, p. 28-45.
MAXWEL, Gabrielle. A Justiça restaurativa na Nova Zelândia. In: Slakmon, C., R. De Vitto, e R. Gomes Pinto (ed). Justiça Restaurativa, Brasília (DF): Ministério da Justiça e Programa das Nações Unidas para o Desenvolvimento (PNUD), 2005, p. 281-296.
MORRIS, Allison. Critiquing the Critics: A Brief Response to Critics a Restorative Justice. British Journal of Criminology [UK], v. 42, 2002, p. 596-615.
MORRISON, B. Justiça Restaurativa nas Escolas. In: Justiça Restaurativa. Brasília: Ministério da Justiça/ Programa das Nações Unidas para o Desenvolvimento (PNUD), 2005, p. 295-319.
PAVLICH, George. Deconstructing restoration: the promise of restorative justice. In: A Restorative Justice Reader, Gerry Johnstone (Ed), William Publishing, UK, 2003, p.451-460.
PATERSON, Craig; CLAMP, Kerry. Exploring recent developments in restorative policing in England and Wales. Criminology & Criminal Justice, [UK], v. 12, n.5, 2012, p. 593-611.
PINTO, Renato Sócrates Gomes. A construção da justiça restaurativa no Brasil - o impacto no sistema de justiça criminal. Revista Paradigma, (18). 2011.
Disponível em: https://revistas.unaerp.br/paradigma/article/view/54 Acesso em: 02 set. 2021.
PRICHARD, Jeremy. Net-Widening and the Diversion of Young People from Court: A Longitudinal Analysis with Implications for Restorative Justice. The Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology, [AU], v. 43, n.1, 2010, p. 112–129.
PRUDENTE, Neemias Moretti; SABADELL, Ana Lucia. Mudança de Paradigma: Justiça Restaurativa. Revista Jurídica Cesumar, v. 8, n. 1, 2008, p. 49-62.
ROLIM, Marcos. Desistência do Crime. Sociedade e Estado, nº 33 (3), 2018, p. 829-847.
ROLIM, Marcos. Justiça Restaurativa e Assédio Moral. Novos Estudos Jurídicos, 2021, p. 530-543.
ROLIM, Marcos. Justiça restaurativa em prisões. Pensar, Revista de Ciências Jurídicas, v. 27, p. 1-13, 2022.
ROSEMBLAT, Fernanda Fonseca; RODRIGUES, Sarah Vieira; FALCÃO, Renata Soares Ramos. O Que Há Fora da Caixa do Menor Potencial Ofensivo? Um Prelúdio à Aplicação da Justiça Restaurativa em Crimes “Graves” Sob as Lentes da Organização das Nações Unidas. Revista Direito Público, Brasília, v. 19, n. 103, 2022, p. 337-359.
SALM, João; LEAL, Jackson da Silva. A Justiça Restaurativa: multidimensionalidade humana e seu convidado de honra. Sequência, n. 64, 2012, p. 195-226.
SCHUCH, Patrice. Tecnologias da não-violência e modernização da justiça no Brasil: o caso da justiça restaurativa. Civitas, Porto Alegre, v.8, n. 3, 2008, p. 498-520.
SECCO, Márcio; LIMA, Elivânia Patrícia de. Justiça restaurativa – problemas e perspectivas, Rev. Direito e Práxis, Rio de Janeiro, v. 9, n. 1, 2018, p. 443-460.
SHAPLAND, Joanna; CRAWFORD, Adam; GRAY, Emily; BURN, Daniel. Restorative justice at the level of the police in England: implementing change. Centre for Criminological Research, University of Sheffield (UK), 2017.
Disponível em: https://www.sheffield.ac.uk/polopoly_fs/1.743733! /file/DevelopingRestorativePolicing3.pdf . Acesso em: 22 jul. 2020.
SKELTON, Ann. Restorative Justice as a Framework for Juvenile Justice Reform, a South African Perspective. British Journal of Criminology [UK], 42, 2002, p. 496-513.
SOUZA, Edson Luiz André de; ZÜGE, Márcia Barcellos Alves. Direito à Palavra: Interrogações Acerca Da Proposta Da Justiça Restaurativa, Psicologia: Ciência e Profissão, 31 (4), 2011, p. 826-839
STAMATAKIS, Nikolaos; VANDEVIVER, Christophe. Restorative justice in Belgian prisons: the results of an empirical research, Crime Law Soc Change, (s.l.), 59, 2013, p.79-111.
STRANG, Heather. Restorative Justice Programs in Australia. Research School of Social Sciences, Australian National University [AU], 2001.
STRANG, Heather. Experiments in restorative justice In Regulatory Theory: Foundations and applications, edited by Peter Drahos, ANU Press, The Australian National University, Canberra, Australia, 2017.
TAPIAS, Camila de Gamboa. La justicia restaurativa en la justicia transicional: una reflexión general para el caso colombiano, Capaz – Instituto Colombo Aleman para la Paz. Bogotá, Colombia, 2020. Disponível em: https://www.instituto-capaz.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/DT-4-2020-web.pdf Acesso em: 05 jan. 2021.
VAN NESS, D. Crime, and its victims: what can we do? Downers Grove, IL [US]: Intervarsity Press, 1986.
VAN NESS, D. Restorative Justice as World View, ESRC Seminar Series: Restorative Approaches to Conflict in Schools, Seminar 2: International Perspectives on RA, University of Cambridge [UK], June 21-22, 2010.
WARD, Tony; FOX, Kathryn J.; GARBER, Melissa. Restorative justice, offender rehabilitation and desistance, Restorative Justice, [s.l.], 2:1, 2014, p. 24-42.
YAZZIE, Robert; ZION, James. Navajo Restorative Justice: the law of equality and justice. In: A Restorative Justice Reader, Gerry Johnstone (Ed), William Publishing, UK, p. 144-151, 2003, p.144-151.
ZEHR, Howard. The Little Book of Restorative Justice, Intercourse, PA [US], Good Books, 2002.
ZEHR, Howard. Trocando as Lentes: um novo foco sobre o crime e a justiça. São Paulo, Palas Athena, 2008.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2023 Marcos Rolim
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Copyrights for any articles published in the journal are given to the author and RDFD with first publication rights granted to the Journal. By virtue of their appearance in this open access journal, articles are free to use, with proper attribution, for educational and other non-commercial purposes in accordance with the creative commons.
