BETWEEN MILITANT DEMOCRACY AND CITIZEN VIGILANTISM:
USING CITIZENS’ ASSEMBLIES TO KEEP PARTIES DEMOCRATIC
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.25192/ISSN.1982-0496.RDFD.V.29.II.2806Abstract
The essential role of parties in democracies makes it important to keep them democratic. This article argues for sortition-based citizens’ assemblies (CAs) organized in and by civil society to formulate democratic standards for political parties to follow, to evaluate them individually and to criticize them publicly if they do not. This is a third and potentially complementary way to keeping parties democratic, placed between militant democracy on the one hand and citizen vigilantism on the other. Militant democracy is challenged by the fact that few democratically problematic parties are ostensibly anti-democratic and therefore likely to fall under the legal criteria for issuing party bans and other legal sanctions. Militant democratic measures are also likely to be ineffective and are vulnerable to abuse. Citizen vigilantism, whereby active democratic citizens take on the responsibility for protecting democracy, deals better with the ambiguous nature of democratically problematic parties but suffers from a lack of democratic authorization and clear standards of critique. While not perfect, the proposed model remedies many of the shortcomings of both approaches. Contributing to an emerging literature on CAs as instruments in the protection of democracy, the article evaluates the model’s normative justifiability, feasibility and likely effectiveness.
Keywords: citizen vigilantism; militant democracy; denunciation and shame; party regulation; assembly of citizens based on lottery
Downloads
References
ABIZADEH, Arash. 2021. ‘Representation, Bicameralism, Political Equality, and Sortition: Reconstituting the Second Chamber as a Randomly Selected Assembly’. Perspectives on Politics 19(3):791–806.
AKKERMAN, Tjitske, Sarah L de Lange and Matthijs Rooduijn. 2016. Radical Right-Wing Populist Parties in Western Europe: Into the Mainstream? London: Routledge.
Berkey, Brian. 2021. ‘Ethical Consumerism, Democratic Values, and Justice’. Philosophy & Public Affairs 49 (3): 237–74.
BÉRTOA, Fernando C., DR Piccio and Ekaterina R Rashkova. 2014. Party laws in comparative perspective. In Regulating Political Parties European Democracies in Comparative Perspective, edited by Ingrid Van Biezen and Hans-Martien Ten Napel, 119–48. Leiden: Leiden University Press.
BHAGWAT, Ashutosh and James Weinstein. 2021. ‘Freedom of Expression and Democracy’. In The Oxford Handbook of Freedom of Speech, edited by Adrienne Stone and Frederick Schauer, 82–105. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
BOURNE, Angela. 2012. ‘The Proscription of Political Parties and Militant Democracy’. Journal of Comparative Law 7:196–213.
BOURNE, Angela. 2023. ‘Initiatives Opposing Populist Parties in Europe: Types, Methods, and Patterns’. Comparative European Politics 21(6):742–60.
BRETTSCHNEIDER, Corey. 2009. Democratic Rights. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
BUTTON, Mark E and JACOB Garrett. 2016. ‘Impartiality in Political Judgment: Deliberative Not Philosophical’. Political Studies, 64(1_suppl):35–52.
ÇALIŞKAN, Koray. 2018. ‘Toward a New Political Regime in Turkey: From Competitive Toward Full Authoritarianism’. New Perspectives on Turkey 58:5–33.
CAMPO, Francesco. 2023. ‘Differentiated Opposition in Collective Mobilization: Countering Italian Populism’. Comparative European Politics 21(6):779–98.
CAPOCCIA, Giovanni. 2013. ‘Militant Democracy: The Institutional Bases of Democratic Self-Preservation’. Annual Review of Law and Social Science 9:207–26.
CHRISTENSEN, Henrik S. 2019. ‘Boosting Political Trust with Direct Democracy? The Case of the Finnish Citizens’ Initiative’. Politics and Governance 7(2):173–86.
CURATO, Nicole, Julien Vrydagh and André Bächtiger. 2020. ‘Democracy Without Shortcuts: Introduction to the Special Issue’. Journal of Deliberative Democracy 16(2):1–9.
DALY, Tom Gerald and BRIAN Christopher Jones. 2020. ‘Parties versus Democracy: Addressing Today’s Political Party Threats to Democratic Rule’. International Journal of Constitutional Law 18(2):509–38.
DOWNS, William M. 2012. Political Extremism in Democracies: Combating Intolerance. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
ELSTER, Jon. 1995. ‘Forces and Mechanisms in the Constitution-Making Process’. Duke Law Journal 45(2): 364–96.
FARRELL, David Mand Peter Stone. 2020. ‘Sortition and Mini-Publics: A Different Kind of Representation’. The Oxford Handbook of Political Representation in Liberal Democracies, edited by Robert Rohrschneider and Jacques Thomassen, Ch 11. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
FISHKIN, James, Alice Siu, Larry Diamond and Norman Bradburn. 2021. ‘Is Deliberation an Antidote to Extreme Partisan Polarization? Reflections on “America in One Room”’. American Political Science Review 115(4): 1464–81.
FOURNIER, Patrick, Henk van der Kolk, R Kenneth Carty, André BLAIS and Johnny ROSE. 2011. When Citizens Decide: Lessons from Citizen Assemblies on Electoral Reform. New York: Oxford University Press.
FOX, Gregory H and Georg NOLTE. 1995. ‘Intolerant Democracies’. Harvard International Law Journal 36(1): 1–70.
GASTIL, John, Elizabeth ROSENZWEIG, Katherine R KNOBLOCH and David BRINKER. 2016. ‘Does the Public Want Mini Publics? Voter Responses to the Citizens’ Initiative Review’. Communication and the Public 1(2): 174–92.
GILABERT, Pablo and Holly LAWFORD-SMITH. 2012. ‘Political Feasibility: A Conceptual Exploration’. Political Studies 60(4):809–25.
GOODIN, Robert E and John S DRYZEK. 2006. ‘Deliberative Impacts: The Macro-political Uptake of Minipublics’. Politics & Society 34(2):219–44.
HABERMAS, Jürgen R. 1996. Between Facts and Norms: Contributions to a Discourse Theory of Law and Democracy. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
HAMDAOUI, Soraya. 2022. ‘A “Stylistic Anti-populism”: An Analysis of the Sardine Movement’s Opposition to Matteo Salvini in Italy’. Social Movement Studies 21(4): 436–52.
HEINISCH, Reinhard and Carsten WEGSCHEIDER. 2020. ‘Disentangling How Populism and Radical Host Ideologies Shape Citizens’ Conceptions of Democratic Decision-making’. Politics and Governance 8(3): 32–44.
HEINZE, Anna-Sophie. 2022. ‘Dealing with the Populist Radical Right in Parliament: Mainstream Party Responses Toward the Alternative for Germany’. European Political Science Review 14(3):333–50. Herman, Lise E. 2017. ‘Democratic Partisanship: From Theoretical Ideal to Empirical Standard’. American Political Science Review 111(4):738–54.
JACOBS, Kristof. 2023. ‘Populists and Citizens’ Assemblies: Caught Between Strategy and Principles?’ In De Gruyter Handbook of Citizens Assemblies, edited by Welp Yanina, Min Reuchamps and Julian Vrydagh, 349–63. Berlin: De Gruyter.
JACOBS, Laura and Joost Van SPANJE. 2020. ‘Prosecuted, Yet Popular? Hate Speech Prosecution of Antiimmigration Politicians in the News and Electoral Support’. Comparative European Politics 18:899–924.
JOINT COMMITTEE ON THE CONSTITUTION. 2010. Fourth Report. Dublin: House of the Oireachtas.
KARVONEN, Lauri. 2007. ‘Legislation on Political Parties: A Global Comparison’. Party Politics 13(4):437–55.
KELEMEN, R Daniel. 2020. ‘The European Union’s Authoritarian Equilibrium’. Journal of European Public Policy 27(3):481–99.
KHAITAN, Tarun. 2020. ‘Political Parties in Constitutional Theory’. Current Legal Problems 73(1):89–125.
KIRSHNER, Alexander S. 2014. A Theory of Militant Democracy: The Ethics of Combatting Political Extremism. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press. Kitschelt, Herbert. 2008. ‘Parties and Political Intermediation’. In The Blackwell Companion to Political Sociology, edited by Kate Nash and Alan Scott, 149–63. Malden, MA: Blackwell.
LAFONT, Cristina. 2017. ‘Can Democracy Be Deliberative & Participatory? The Democratic Case for Political Uses of Mini-publics’. Daedalus 146(3):85–105.
LAFONT, Cristina. 2019. Democracy Without Shortcuts: A Participatory Conception of Deliberative Democracy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
LANDA, Dimitri and Ryan Pevnick. 2021. ‘Is Random Selection a Cure for the Ills of Electoral Representation?’ Journal of Political Philosophy 29(1):46–72.
LANDAU, David. 2013. ‘Abusive Constitutionalism’. UCDL Review 47(1):189–260.
LAUMOND, Bénédicte. 2023. ‘Increasing Toleration for the Intolerant? “Adapted militancy” and German Responses to Alternative für Deutschland’. Comparative European Politics 21(2):1–18.
LINDELL, Michael. 2023. ‘Internal Dynamics at Work’. In De Gruyter Handbook of Citizens Assemblies, edited by Welp Yanina, Min Reuchamps and Julian Vrydagh, 257–70. Berlin: De Gruyter.
LOEWENSTEIN, Karl. 1937a. ‘Militant Democracy and Fundamental Eights, I’. American Political Science Review 31(3):417–32.
LOEWENSTEIN, Karl. 1937b. ‘Militant Democracy and Fundamental Rights, II’. American Political Science Review 31(4):638–58.
LONGO, Erik. 2019. ‘The European Citizens’ Initiative: Too Much Democracy for EU Polity?’. German Law Journal 20(2):181–200.
MERCIER, Hugo and Hélène LANDEMORE. 2012. ‘Reasoning is for Arguing: Understanding the Successes and Failures of Deliberation’. Political Psychology 33(2)243–58.
MOLIER, Gelijn and Bastiaan RIJPKEMA. 2018. ‘Germany’s New Militant Democracy Regime: National Democratic Party II and the German Federal Constitutional Court’s “Potentiality” Criterion for Party Bans: Bundesverfassungsgericht, Judgment of 17 January 2017, 2 BvB 1/13, National Democratic Party II’. European Constitutional Law Review 14(2):394–409.
MOORE, Alfred. 2023. ‘Parties and Partisanship in Political Theory’. In The Routledge Handbook of Political Parties, edited by Neil Carter, Daniel Keith, Gyda M Sindre and Sfodia Vasilopoulou, 20–29. London: Routledge.
MOROSKA-BONKIEWICZ, Aleksandra and Katarzyna DOMAGAŁA. 2023. ‘Opposing Populists in Power: How and Why Polish Civil Society Europeanised Their Opposition to the Rule of Law Crisis in Poland’. Comparative European Politics 21:817–33.
MUIRHEAD, Russel and Nancy L ROSENBLUM. 2020. ‘The Political Theory of Parties and Partisanship: Catching Up’. Annual Review of Political Science 23:95–110.
Müller, Jan-Werner. 2012. ‘A “Practical Dilemma Which Philosophy Alone Cannot Resolve”? Rethinking Militant Democracy: An Introduction’. Constellations 19(4):536–39.
MÜLLER, Jan-Werner. 2022. ‘Citizens as Militant Democrats, or: Just How Intolerant Should the People Be?’ Critical Review 34(1):85–98.
MURADOVA, Lala. 2021. ‘Seeing the Other Side? Perspective-Taking and Reflective Political Judgements in Interpersonal Deliberation’. Political Studies 69(3):644–64.
Myers, C Daniel. 2022. ‘The Dynamics of Social Identity: Evidence from Deliberating Groups’. Political Psychology 43(2):237–54.
OLSEN, Tore V. 2022. ‘Citizens’ Actions Against Non-Liberal-Democratic Parties’. European Constitutional Law Review 18(3):466–87.
OLSEN, Tore V. 2023. Why and How Should the European Union Defend Its Values? Res Publica 29(1):69–88.
PATEMAN, Carole. 2012. ‘Participatory Democracy Revisited’. Perspectives on Politics 10(1):7–19.
RAWLS, John. 1971. A Theory of Justice. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
RENWICK, Alan, Kaela SCOTT, Meg RUSSELL, James CLEAVER and Frances OSBORNE. 2022. Report of the Citizens Assembly on Democracy in the UK. London: The Constitution Unit School of Public Policy University College London.
RIJPKEMA, Bastiaan. 2018. Militant Democracy: The Limits of Democratic Tolerance. London: Routledge.
RISSE, Thomas, Kathryn SIKKINK and Stephen C ROPP. 1999. ‘The Socialization of International Human Rights Norms into Domestic Practices. Domestic Politics and Norm Diffusion in International Relations, edited by Thomas Risse, 117–59. London: Routledge.
ROSENBLUM, Nancy L. 2010. On the Side of the Angels. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
SAJÓ, András. 2019. ‘Militant Constitutionalism’. In Militant Democracy and Its Critics: Populism, Parties, Extremism, edited by Anthoula Malkopoulou and Alexander S Kirshner, 187–206. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
SARTORI, Giovanni. 1976. Parties and Party Systems: A Framework for Analysis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
SCHATTSCHNEIDER, Elmer E. 1942. Party Government. New Brunswick, NH: Transaction.
SCHILLER, Theo and Maija Setälä. 2012. ‘Comparative Findings’. In Citizens’ Initiatives in Europe, edited by Maija Setälä and Theo Schiller, 243–59. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
SEDELMEIER, Ulrich. 2017. ‘Political Safeguards Against Democratic Backsliding in the EU: The Limits of Material Sanctions and the Scope of Social Pressure’. Journal of European Public Policy 24(3):337–51.
SETÄLÄ, Maija and Kaisa HERNE. 2014. ‘Normative Theory and Experimental Research in the Study of Deliberative Mini-publics’. In Deliberative Mini-Publics, edited by Kimmo Grönlund, André Bächtiger and Maija Setälä, 59–76, Colchester: ECPR Press.
SIMMONS, A John. 2010. ‘Ideal and nonideal theory’. Philosophy & Public Affairs 38(1):5–36.
STEINER, Jurg. 2012. ‘Favorable Consequences of Deliberation. In The Foundations of Deliberative Democracy: Empirical Research and Normative Implications, 219–46. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
STONE, Peter and Anthoula Malkopoulou. 2022. ‘Allotted Chambers as Defenders of Democracy’. Constellations 29(3):296–309.
TALUKDER, Dipongkar and Jean-Beniot PILET. 2023. ‘Citizens’ Support for Citizens’ Assemblies’. In De Gruyter Handbook of Citizens Assemblies, edited by Welp Yanina, Min Reuchamps and Julian Vrydagh, 313–24. Berlin: De Gruyter.
TUOVINEN, Juha. 2023. ‘Resisting ambiguously anti-democratic parties: What role for the state, political parties and civil society?’ Comparative European Politics 21(6): 834–847.
VAN ERP, Judith. 2021. ‘Shaming and Compliance’. In The Cambridge Handbook of Compliance, edited by Benjamin van Rooij and Daniel Sokol, 438–50. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
VINX, Lars. 2020. ‘Democratic Equality and Militant Democracy’. Constellations 27(4):685–701.
WALDRON, Jeremy. 2005. ‘Compared to What? Judicial Activism and New Zealand’s Parliament’. New Zealand Law Journal 1, 441–45.
WALDRON, Jeremy. 2016. Political Theory: Essays on Institutions. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
WOLKENSTEIN, Fabio. 2022a. ‘European Political Parties’ Complicity in Democratic Backsliding’. Global Constitutionalism 11(1):55–82.
WOLKENSTEIN, Fabio. 2022b. ‘What is Democratic Backsliding?’ Constellations 30(3):261–75.
ZALAN, Eszter. 2022. ‘When the EU Found the Political Will to Act on Rule of Law. ’. EU Observer, 28 December. Available at <https://euobserver.com/rule-of-law/156556>.
ZASLOVE, Andrej, Bram Geurkink, Kristof Jacobs and Agnes Akkerman. 2021. ‘Power to the People? Populism, Democracy, and Political Participation: A Citizen’s Perspective’. West European Politics 44(4):727–51.
WOLKENSTEIN, Fabio. 2022b. ‘What is Democratic Backsliding?’ Constellations.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Tore Vincents Olsen, Juha
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Copyrights for any articles published in the journal are given to the author and RDFD with first publication rights granted to the Journal. By virtue of their appearance in this open access journal, articles are free to use, with proper attribution, for educational and other non-commercial purposes in accordance with the creative commons.
